The most successful productizing companies have a product organizational structure that is driven by and aligned with a well-articulated vision and goals for the productization strategy. A product org structure that is misaligned with the goals of the productization strategy puts great product ideas at risk of lackluster performance, racking up costs, or never making it to launch in the first place.
Organizational structure has been a hot topic in our Product Leader Peer Groups for several sessions now.
Questions include:
The participants represent a variety of organizational structures, but one takeaway has been consistently clear:
To successfully productize, you need an organizational structure that flows from your product vision.
A case in point: a large global consulting firm recently asked for our help in helping them develop the best org structure for both existing product management and the development of new products. They had modest success in developing a portfolio of productized solutions but leadership recognized that to accelerate productization and deliver on their ambitious growth goals, the firm needed to make substantial changes to their product org structure.
We found that our clients’ structure wasn’t operating with the agility they sought. The current structure dispersed accountability for each new phase of product development to more than one individual. And conflicting ideas about who was responsible for the components of existing product management made it difficult to oversee the entire product portfolio. For example, when we surveyed the leadership team about who was responsible for customer discovery (customer research, competitive landscape assessment, etc.) for one particular line of business, at least four different people/parts of the organization were cited.
The result? Duplication of efforts, under-performing and under-resourced products, and a glacial pace for new product launches and releasing existing product improvements. None of these outcomes spoke to the successful implementation of a market-responsive product vision.
To effectively redesign their structure to support the velocity of new product development and the management of established products, our client needed to redesign their structure to support both activities. This is not easy. Restructuring product org structures brings disruption to daily workflows, operations, reporting lines, and job descriptions, and we risk losing key staff and delaying new product releases.
That said, choosing the right org structure for product management and new product innovation can go a long way in improving time to market, increasing the likelihood of developing products with strong product-market fit, and growth of existing products.
In this article, we describe 3 basic organizational structures that support product development and management activities, how they support specific visions, and some of the risks and benefits of each. These structures include:
Successful productization requires organizational structures that make it easy to generate, design, and test new product ideas at the outset, and which can evolve to promote strong oversight over the existing product portfolio as an organization’s maturity advances. There are nuances to getting org structure right, not least of which is your company’s current architecture and strategy. That said, most product development and management activities can thrive within a centralized, decentralized, or hybrid/matrixed organizational structure.
For organizations that want new products to be incubated but also have existing products that are sold as part of or alongside existing services, hybrid structures can be extremely effective.
But it is important to note that matrixed structures may also bring the less attractive features of both centralized and decentralized models to the table. Matrixed org structures take more time to manage across because there are multiple priorities to be weighed. As such, the product managers in the business need to be more experienced, influential and politically savvy. Firms may need to fund a dedicated product sales team, while products get traction in the existing divisional sales channels. This model also requires additional governance to ensure comprehensive oversight of the product portfolio as innovation activities flourish across the organization.
These models are a starting point, and it is important to recognize that your organization will very likely need to customize a centralized, decentralized, or mixed structure to best fit your vision and existing needs. They are also simplified: the right structure for your firm will need to account for business complexity, geography, and the structure of existing product roles (if applicable).
Keep in mind, too, that your organizational structure will likely evolve over time. Product development and management actually require, at least for a time, slightly different organizational models that can facilitate the varying activities that are associated with each. Moreover, as businesses mature in their productization capabilities, their org structures must evolve too.
For example, if your organization chooses to go big now and make product a significant part of revenue, you will need a centralized, incubated structure to start. But as product becomes more established, you should anticipate a shift to a more decentralized model. If your organization is starting slow with plans to accelerate product later, a decentralized model will work well at the outset, but you may want to shift to a centralized model to speed up. And there may be a need to downshift back into a decentralized model as product becomes a significant source of revenue.
The key point here is that as the vision and strategic goals for product changes, the organizational structure should evolve in response. The best product leaders understand that organizational structures are fluid, because goals change over time.
We love thinking through the intricacies of organizational structure, and can help your firm design the structure that best fits your product vision and strategy. If you would like to learn more about how we can help you design your product structure, please schedule some time.
For the bigger picture, see the Vecteris complete guide to productization and our view on organizational design for product-led services firms.